The simplest (conceptually) way to check it is to perform PZ analysis. The real passive elements has ca 10% parasitic capacitance to ground which modifies transfer function. There is also a question about your opamp PZ location. By closing the loop, any opamp zero is forming directly a pole.
Start with model of opamp and PZ analysis. Maybe split filter to low pass and high pass circuits can help in debugging.
//edit
Please notice your peak has only 0.5dB, it is not too much