+ Post New Thread
Results 1 to 8 of 8
-
5th October 2019, 13:45 #1
- Join Date
- Sep 2008
- Location
- cambridge
- Posts
- 6,955
- Helped
- 509 / 509
- Points
- 33,487
- Level
- 44
PCB flexion and cracking of SMD capacitors
Hi,
For the following nine SMD ceramic capacitors on a PCB, which capacitor would you say is most likely to suffer cracking?
I am talking about cracking due to board flexion. This board gets screwed down to a metal heatsink, with a bit of thermal conductive rubber pad between board and heatsink.
-
Advertisement
-
5th October 2019, 14:01 #2
- Join Date
- Feb 2014
- Posts
- 903
- Helped
- 298 / 298
- Points
- 6,274
- Level
- 18
Re: PCB flexion and cracking of SMD capacitors
See figure 8 in this document discusses exactly this:
https://www.digikey.com/Site/Global/...403C3540CC7267
Flexing the long way is the worst
In your diagram A is worst, B is next. Everything away from the edges is better.
-
Advertisement
-
5th October 2019, 14:08 #3
- Join Date
- Nov 2012
- Posts
- 3,251
- Helped
- 808 / 808
- Points
- 17,814
- Level
- 32
Re: PCB flexion and cracking of SMD capacitors
Assume the screws are nicely fixed; then major flexing can occur only on the long axis. Components that are mounted along this length shall experience the greatest stress.
I presume that components mounted along the length (long axis parallel to the length of the board) are most likely to suffer cracking.
Near the edges, there is some relief (temp will be highest in the centre) and out of all the components mounted longitudinally, G will see the largest stress.
But because of its size, this is also most securely fastened.
-
Advertisement
-
5th October 2019, 14:23 #4
- Join Date
- Jan 2008
- Location
- Bochum, Germany
- Posts
- 45,804
- Helped
- 13926 / 13926
- Points
- 262,101
- Level
- 100
Re: PCB flexion and cracking of SMD capacitors
This board gets screwed down to a metal heatsink, with a bit of thermal conductive rubber pad between board and heatsink.
You should use a soft thermal gap filler instead of a rubber pad.
-
5th October 2019, 16:24 #5
- Join Date
- Sep 2008
- Location
- cambridge
- Posts
- 6,955
- Helped
- 509 / 509
- Points
- 33,487
- Level
- 44
Re: PCB flexion and cracking of SMD capacitors
Thanks for this
https://www.digikey.com/Site/Global/...403C3540CC7267
...figure 1 of this suggests to me that we would be best off screweing in our centre screw first, because then that will lead to concave bending, which is better for the capacitor?
I wish soft-termination caps were more common, and that lead-frame MLCC's were cheaper.
Also, its strange that the document doenst say anything about flex cracking and capacitor size...because i believe the bigger a capacitor, the more susceptible it is to flex cracking.?
Also, to reduce depanelisation cracking, i believe a slot can be routed along the board edge to mitigate this.....the slot extending 5mm further (in each direction) than the edge of the capacitor under threat.?
-
5th October 2019, 17:41 #6
- Join Date
- Nov 2012
- Posts
- 3,251
- Helped
- 808 / 808
- Points
- 17,814
- Level
- 32
Re: PCB flexion and cracking of SMD capacitors
.because i believe the bigger a capacitor, the more susceptible it is to flex cracking...
Bigger size also means physical strength. But how does it scale?
Flexing causes bending stress; for a given amount of flexing, the stress will be now proportional to the area of contact with the board.
But the stain will be depending on the length of the component along the direction of flexing.
But see post #4; perhaps plastic clamps along the edges will be the most preferred solution?
-
5th October 2019, 23:17 #7
- Join Date
- Jun 2001
- Location
- In the sewers of the U.K.
- Posts
- 889
- Helped
- 85 / 85
- Points
- 9,679
- Level
- 23
Re: PCB flexion and cracking of SMD capacitors
All the above and ISTR that it was shown that by having the pad narrower than the capacitor ends, cracking was reduced.
However its been so long since I read the article on it that I have no idea who it was by (cannot remember).Please do not PM me questions that are better asked in the PCB forum :)
-
Advertisement
-
5th October 2019, 23:57 #8
- Join Date
- Feb 2014
- Posts
- 903
- Helped
- 298 / 298
- Points
- 6,274
- Level
- 18
Re: PCB flexion and cracking of SMD capacitors
Yes size makes a big difference. I've been told by sales reps to stay 1206 and below when possible.
We've had big problems with 18XX and larger ceramics failing. None with anything smaller.
In my experience soft term is quite common at 1206 and above.
At this point I avoid large ceramics in favor of film if at all possible. When you take into account the horrendous C versus V curve of ceramics the size difference isn't as big as it seems.
+ Post New Thread
Please login