Thanks shahid78,
I forget something, but I correct it in the previous post (see the EDIT).
In the application, I will show how to calculate the reflection phase for several methos in TD and FD.
I correct also the macro for phase reflection (calculate for vaccuum structure, then pec structure and the real structure).
Maybe I will include dispersion diagram.
This application is nearly ready but in french, I have to translate it.
I think in January it will be finished.
regards
piboo
PS: If I helped someone... +1 for help will be nice