g86
Full Member level 4
- Joined
- Jan 21, 2003
- Messages
- 212
- Helped
- 11
- Reputation
- 22
- Reaction score
- 7
- Trophy points
- 1,298
- Location
- On top of antenna :))
- Activity points
- 2,232
mwpro said:for circuit level sim, i recpmmend @@DS. for em structure inside the design, I recommend ie3d + @ds. Forget about momentum.
cheng said:IE3D good on MMIC or RF design? Tasteless joke I guess....
A program that does not have sound calibration and is horrible in accuracy can NEVER be good in MMIC design...
Momentum is Slow but is times more accurate.
On oscilator and amplifier designs most of the tools on the list will do the job if the designer is any good. Else, the best simulator will derail.
@DS seems to score best to me in terms of integrity. @DS environment is like an environment one can do everything inside - from simple arithmetic to Matrix computation, plus calls to Vee and Matlab. No other tool's so integrated I reckon. Plus, one can export the design to CST MWS as well.
Indeed, the learning curve is somewhat longer though.
cheers,
cheng
cheng said:IE3D good on MMIC or RF design? Tasteless joke I guess....
A program that does not have sound calibration and is horrible in accuracy can NEVER be good in MMIC design...
Momentum is Slow but is times more accurate.
On oscilator and amplifier designs most of the tools on the list will do the job if the designer is any good. Else, the best simulator will derail.
@DS seems to score best to me in terms of integrity. @DS environment is like an environment one can do everything inside - from simple arithmetic to Matrix computation, plus calls to Vee and Matlab. No other tool's so integrated I reckon. Plus, one can export the design to CST MWS as well.
Indeed, the learning curve is somewhat longer though.
cheers,
cheng
jwei363 said:It's no use to compare different type of things.
@DS,MWO,APLAC for General system,circuit sim
CST MWS,IE3D,HFSS for EM sim
Serenade,Genesys for some kind of circuits sim
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?