sadat007
Full Member level 4
Hi to all,
Beware all users of Protel99SE-SP6, including me using this software since long time.
I faced some serious problem in the autoroute feature of this software.
It short the tracks (one track-short violation is very common).
See the following extrem serious result
Protel Design System Design Rule Check
PCB File : Documents\Copy (1) of lanram2.PCB
Date : 11-Dec-2004
Time : 21:19:33
Processing Rule : Short-Circuit Constraint (Allowed=Not Allowed) (On the board ),(On the board )
Violation between Track (16239mil,11507mil)(16239mil,11795mil) TopLayer and
Track (16243mil,11381mil)(16243mil,11840mil) TopLayer
Violation between Track (16185.929mil,11798mil)(16236mil,11798mil) TopLayer and
Track (16243mil,11381mil)(16243mil,11840mil) TopLayer
Violation between Track (16236mil,11798mil)(16239mil,11795mil) TopLayer and
Track (16243mil,11381mil)(16243mil,11840mil) TopLayer
Violation between Via (16239mil,11507mil) TopLayer to BottomLayer and
Track (16243mil,11381mil)(16243mil,11840mil) TopLayer
Violation between Track (17571mil,11436mil)(17619mil,11388mil) TopLayer and
Track (17448mil,11391mil)(17614mil,11391mil) TopLayer
Violation between Track (17619mil,11335mil)(17619mil,11388mil) TopLayer and
Track (17448mil,11391mil)(17614mil,11391mil) TopLayer
Violation between Track (17571mil,11436mil)(17619mil,11388mil) TopLayer and
Track (17614mil,11391mil)(17614mil,11525mil) TopLayer
Violation between Track (17619mil,11335mil)(17619mil,11388mil) TopLayer and
Track (17614mil,11391mil)(17614mil,11525mil) TopLayer
Violation between Track (17728mil,11059mil)(17728mil,11257mil) TopLayer and
Track (17677mil,11078mil)(17728mil,11078mil) TopLayer
Violation between Track (17728mil,11059mil)(17728mil,11257mil) TopLayer and
Track (17728mil,11078mil)(17728mil,11291mil) TopLayer
Violation between Track (17701mil,11284mil)(17728mil,11257mil) TopLayer and
Track (17728mil,11078mil)(17728mil,11291mil) TopLayer
Violation between Via (17701mil,11284mil) TopLayer to BottomLayer and
Track (17728mil,11078mil)(17728mil,11291mil) TopLayer
Violation between Via (17701mil,11284mil) TopLayer to BottomLayer and
Track (17652mil,11367mil)(17728mil,11291mil) TopLayer
Violation between Via (17598mil,10830mil) TopLayer to BottomLayer and
Track (17621mil,10807mil)(17632mil,10796mil) TopLayer
Violation between Via (17598mil,10830mil) TopLayer to BottomLayer and
Track (17621mil,10807mil)(17621mil,10864mil) TopLayer
Violation between Via (17598mil,10830mil) TopLayer to BottomLayer and
Track (17621mil,10864mil)(17630mil,10873mil) TopLayer
Violation between Via (16540mil,11674mil) TopLayer to BottomLayer and
Track (16545mil,11720mil)(16654mil,11611mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (16654mil,11584mil)(16759mil,11479mil) BottomLayer and
Track (16664mil,11550mil)(16714mil,11550mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (16654mil,11584mil)(16759mil,11479mil) BottomLayer and
Track (16714mil,11500mil)(16714mil,11550mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (16654mil,11584mil)(16759mil,11479mil) BottomLayer and
Track (16726mil,11488mil)(16874mil,11488mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (16759mil,11479mil)(16805mil,11479mil) BottomLayer and
Track (16726mil,11488mil)(16874mil,11488mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (16805mil,11479mil)(16814mil,11488mil) BottomLayer and
Track (16726mil,11488mil)(16874mil,11488mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (16814mil,11488mil)(16945mil,11488mil) BottomLayer and
Track (16726mil,11488mil)(16874mil,11488mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (16814mil,11488mil)(16945mil,11488mil) BottomLayer and
Track (16874mil,11488mil)(16874mil,11603mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (16475mil,10108mil)(17395mil,10108mil) BottomLayer and
Track (17403mil,10103mil)(17926mil,10626mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (17395mil,10108mil)(17395mil,10627mil) BottomLayer and
Track (17403mil,10103mil)(17926mil,10626mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (16475mil,10108mil)(17395mil,10108mil) BottomLayer and
Track (16185mil,10103mil)(17403mil,10103mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (16382mil,10201mil)(16475mil,10108mil) BottomLayer and
Track (16185mil,10103mil)(17403mil,10103mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (17395mil,10108mil)(17395mil,10627mil) BottomLayer and
Track (16185mil,10103mil)(17403mil,10103mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (15427mil,11901mil)(15427mil,12533mil) BottomLayer and
Track (15420mil,9980mil)(15420mil,12276mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (15427mil,10463mil)(15427mil,11737mil) BottomLayer and
Track (15420mil,9980mil)(15420mil,12276mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (15427mil,10463mil)(15446mil,10444mil) BottomLayer and
Track (15420mil,9980mil)(15420mil,12276mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (15420mil,11744mil)(15427mil,11737mil) BottomLayer and
Track (15420mil,9980mil)(15420mil,12276mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (15420mil,11744mil)(15420mil,11901mil) BottomLayer and
Track (15420mil,9980mil)(15420mil,12276mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (15420mil,11901mil)(15427mil,11901mil) BottomLayer and
Track (15420mil,9980mil)(15420mil,12276mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Via (15446mil,10444mil) TopLayer to BottomLayer and
Track (15420mil,9980mil)(15420mil,12276mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (15427mil,11901mil)(15427mil,12533mil) BottomLayer and
Track (15420mil,12276mil)(15476mil,12332mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Via (16532mil,11733mil) TopLayer to BottomLayer and
Via (16540mil,11674mil) TopLayer to BottomLayer
Rule Violations :38
Violations Detected : 38
Time Elapsed : 00:00:06
Your comments on this issue is welcome.
Solution: Always run DRC before sending for PCB manufacturer (I did not).
Thanks
Sadat
Beware all users of Protel99SE-SP6, including me using this software since long time.
I faced some serious problem in the autoroute feature of this software.
It short the tracks (one track-short violation is very common).
See the following extrem serious result
Protel Design System Design Rule Check
PCB File : Documents\Copy (1) of lanram2.PCB
Date : 11-Dec-2004
Time : 21:19:33
Processing Rule : Short-Circuit Constraint (Allowed=Not Allowed) (On the board ),(On the board )
Violation between Track (16239mil,11507mil)(16239mil,11795mil) TopLayer and
Track (16243mil,11381mil)(16243mil,11840mil) TopLayer
Violation between Track (16185.929mil,11798mil)(16236mil,11798mil) TopLayer and
Track (16243mil,11381mil)(16243mil,11840mil) TopLayer
Violation between Track (16236mil,11798mil)(16239mil,11795mil) TopLayer and
Track (16243mil,11381mil)(16243mil,11840mil) TopLayer
Violation between Via (16239mil,11507mil) TopLayer to BottomLayer and
Track (16243mil,11381mil)(16243mil,11840mil) TopLayer
Violation between Track (17571mil,11436mil)(17619mil,11388mil) TopLayer and
Track (17448mil,11391mil)(17614mil,11391mil) TopLayer
Violation between Track (17619mil,11335mil)(17619mil,11388mil) TopLayer and
Track (17448mil,11391mil)(17614mil,11391mil) TopLayer
Violation between Track (17571mil,11436mil)(17619mil,11388mil) TopLayer and
Track (17614mil,11391mil)(17614mil,11525mil) TopLayer
Violation between Track (17619mil,11335mil)(17619mil,11388mil) TopLayer and
Track (17614mil,11391mil)(17614mil,11525mil) TopLayer
Violation between Track (17728mil,11059mil)(17728mil,11257mil) TopLayer and
Track (17677mil,11078mil)(17728mil,11078mil) TopLayer
Violation between Track (17728mil,11059mil)(17728mil,11257mil) TopLayer and
Track (17728mil,11078mil)(17728mil,11291mil) TopLayer
Violation between Track (17701mil,11284mil)(17728mil,11257mil) TopLayer and
Track (17728mil,11078mil)(17728mil,11291mil) TopLayer
Violation between Via (17701mil,11284mil) TopLayer to BottomLayer and
Track (17728mil,11078mil)(17728mil,11291mil) TopLayer
Violation between Via (17701mil,11284mil) TopLayer to BottomLayer and
Track (17652mil,11367mil)(17728mil,11291mil) TopLayer
Violation between Via (17598mil,10830mil) TopLayer to BottomLayer and
Track (17621mil,10807mil)(17632mil,10796mil) TopLayer
Violation between Via (17598mil,10830mil) TopLayer to BottomLayer and
Track (17621mil,10807mil)(17621mil,10864mil) TopLayer
Violation between Via (17598mil,10830mil) TopLayer to BottomLayer and
Track (17621mil,10864mil)(17630mil,10873mil) TopLayer
Violation between Via (16540mil,11674mil) TopLayer to BottomLayer and
Track (16545mil,11720mil)(16654mil,11611mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (16654mil,11584mil)(16759mil,11479mil) BottomLayer and
Track (16664mil,11550mil)(16714mil,11550mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (16654mil,11584mil)(16759mil,11479mil) BottomLayer and
Track (16714mil,11500mil)(16714mil,11550mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (16654mil,11584mil)(16759mil,11479mil) BottomLayer and
Track (16726mil,11488mil)(16874mil,11488mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (16759mil,11479mil)(16805mil,11479mil) BottomLayer and
Track (16726mil,11488mil)(16874mil,11488mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (16805mil,11479mil)(16814mil,11488mil) BottomLayer and
Track (16726mil,11488mil)(16874mil,11488mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (16814mil,11488mil)(16945mil,11488mil) BottomLayer and
Track (16726mil,11488mil)(16874mil,11488mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (16814mil,11488mil)(16945mil,11488mil) BottomLayer and
Track (16874mil,11488mil)(16874mil,11603mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (16475mil,10108mil)(17395mil,10108mil) BottomLayer and
Track (17403mil,10103mil)(17926mil,10626mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (17395mil,10108mil)(17395mil,10627mil) BottomLayer and
Track (17403mil,10103mil)(17926mil,10626mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (16475mil,10108mil)(17395mil,10108mil) BottomLayer and
Track (16185mil,10103mil)(17403mil,10103mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (16382mil,10201mil)(16475mil,10108mil) BottomLayer and
Track (16185mil,10103mil)(17403mil,10103mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (17395mil,10108mil)(17395mil,10627mil) BottomLayer and
Track (16185mil,10103mil)(17403mil,10103mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (15427mil,11901mil)(15427mil,12533mil) BottomLayer and
Track (15420mil,9980mil)(15420mil,12276mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (15427mil,10463mil)(15427mil,11737mil) BottomLayer and
Track (15420mil,9980mil)(15420mil,12276mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (15427mil,10463mil)(15446mil,10444mil) BottomLayer and
Track (15420mil,9980mil)(15420mil,12276mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (15420mil,11744mil)(15427mil,11737mil) BottomLayer and
Track (15420mil,9980mil)(15420mil,12276mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (15420mil,11744mil)(15420mil,11901mil) BottomLayer and
Track (15420mil,9980mil)(15420mil,12276mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (15420mil,11901mil)(15427mil,11901mil) BottomLayer and
Track (15420mil,9980mil)(15420mil,12276mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Via (15446mil,10444mil) TopLayer to BottomLayer and
Track (15420mil,9980mil)(15420mil,12276mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Track (15427mil,11901mil)(15427mil,12533mil) BottomLayer and
Track (15420mil,12276mil)(15476mil,12332mil) BottomLayer
Violation between Via (16532mil,11733mil) TopLayer to BottomLayer and
Via (16540mil,11674mil) TopLayer to BottomLayer
Rule Violations :38
Violations Detected : 38
Time Elapsed : 00:00:06
Your comments on this issue is welcome.
Solution: Always run DRC before sending for PCB manufacturer (I did not).
Thanks
Sadat