+ Post New Thread
Results 1 to 10 of 10

3rd September 2019, 19:21 #1
 Join Date
 Jun 2017
 Location
 Bhubaneswar, India
 Posts
 39
 Helped
 4 / 4
 Points
 652
 Level
 5
Exact resistance output?
Hello everyone,
I am facing a problem on creating some resistance. I want to create 100 ohm, 150 ohm, 220 ohm, 470 ohm, 680 ohm and 1.5 kohm using a digital potentiometer. The value will change with the data give to the digital potentiometer. The requirement is to provide this resistance value to two pin output. The Digital potentiometer which is available here is 10 kohm, and 1 kohm will available after few weeks. I am unable create exact values of resistance using this 10 kohm potentiometer.
IC I am using now = AD5254BRUZ1
I have tried to make a parallel connection of these potentiometer like the following image:
Still after the calculation of resistance as per the datasheet I am leaving with some error of 2%3%.
Is there any better solution to this problem, to get exact value of resistance in two pins. Like multiplexing of resistance or something else?
Thank you.

Advertisement

3rd September 2019, 21:55 #2
Awards:
 Join Date
 Apr 2014
 Posts
 15,796
 Helped
 3593 / 3593
 Points
 77,915
 Level
 68
Re: Exact resistance output?
Hi,
Using a 10k pot for a 100 Ohms to 1500 Ohms (1400 ohms)range just uses 14% of it's range.
Try to find a pot with more suitable range.
Or use some parallel resistors to use almost full pot range.
Still after the calculation of resistance as per the datasheet I am leaving with some error of 2%3%.
2% from pot FS is 2% × 10k = 200 Ohms
2% from output FS = 2% × 1500Ohms = 30 Ohms
Or do you talk about 2% deviation from the expected value which then is 2Ohms .. 30Ohms.
And complaining about 2% means nothing when you don's say where your target is.
KlausPlease don´t contact me via PM, because there is no time to respond to them. No friend requests. Thank you.

4th September 2019, 04:05 #3
 Join Date
 Mar 2008
 Location
 USA
 Posts
 6,429
 Helped
 1878 / 1878
 Points
 39,802
 Level
 48
Re: Exact resistance output?
If the resistance desired is "end to end" and the epot likewise
(that is, not a shunttoground or something like that) you could
go for a higher bit count epot, or you could cascade two very
different value epots or parallel them (depending on what's
available; suspect that very low values are not realizable due to
switchFET size requirements)  a 500Kohm 8bit shunt to a 2Kohm
8bit "master" could take you from 8 bits all the way to 16bit resolution
(maybe, or not, as monotonic as you'd like; fix that in software
perhaps?).

Advertisement

4th September 2019, 04:05 #4
 Join Date
 Jan 2019
 Posts
 380
 Helped
 95 / 95
 Points
 2,037
 Level
 10
Re: Exact resistance output?
you have a 10k pot with 256 steps, one of which is 0 and the other is 10k
the step is approximately 39 ohms (10,000/256)
the available values closest to your desired resistances:
you can have 78 or 117, not 100
you can have 117 or 156, not 150
you can have 195 or 234, not 220
you can have 469 or 508, not 470
you can have 664 or 703, not 680
you can have 1484 or 1523, not 1500
unlike a real potentiometer, the digital pot takes digital steps
they may not all be exactly the same size, but it is still a step response
not a rap response
even with a real analog pot, it will not be easy to stop turning at exactly the correct spot,
and there will be backlash
maybe you want to use a digitally controlled analog switch
like TS3A24159DGSR from texas instruments
or 74HC4052 from nexperia
there are lots of others

Advertisement

4th September 2019, 07:54 #5
Awards:
 Join Date
 Apr 2014
 Posts
 15,796
 Helped
 3593 / 3593
 Points
 77,915
 Level
 68
Re: Exact resistance output?
Hi,
maybe you want to use a digitally controlled analog switch
Especially when you want only a couple of fixed, precise values then a MUX and fix resistors is the better solution.
KlausPlease don´t contact me via PM, because there is no time to respond to them. No friend requests. Thank you.

4th September 2019, 08:42 #6
 Join Date
 Jun 2017
 Location
 Bhubaneswar, India
 Posts
 39
 Helped
 4 / 4
 Points
 652
 Level
 5
Re: Exact resistance output?
Thank you so much for your reply. I do not know where this will be used, but I was also thinking the same way.
okay, then I have to select exact value resistance and 8:1 MUX to complete this job.
I have a query regarding the type of resistor, a throughhole or surface mount, is there any problem while selecting the type? Will this affect the circuit? Because right I can go with Throughhole, but SMD for later.
Thank you.

Advertisement

4th September 2019, 13:15 #7
 Join Date
 Jan 2019
 Posts
 380
 Helped
 95 / 95
 Points
 2,037
 Level
 10
Re: Exact resistance output?
analog MUX, not digital MUX
pay attention to the resistance of the switch itself
through hole or surface mount does not matter, provided the components do not overheat
and it will fit in the desired box
tolerance and temperature coefficient are the primary things to pay attention to
you keep saying "exact" resistance
there is always a tolerance,
there is always a temperature coefficient
and there is a very minor resistance variation with voltage that is usually ignored because it is so small
you will have variations in resistance over manufacture, time, temperature and voltage
you need to design the circuit so these do not matter
1 members found this post helpful.

5th September 2019, 02:10 #8
 Join Date
 Mar 2005
 Location
 California, USA
 Posts
 4,661
 Helped
 1032 / 1032
 Points
 24,294
 Level
 37
Re: Exact resistance output?
Your MUX will also have some resistance. And a tolerance.

5th September 2019, 05:40 #9
 Join Date
 Aug 2015
 Posts
 1,824
 Helped
 676 / 676
 Points
 11,225
 Level
 25
Re: Exact resistance output?
You could have a switched array of resistors, 1,2,4,8,16,32,64,128,256,512,1048 ohms
form a simple digital drive and use low RdsON mosfets, you can then get a precision and accuracy of 1 ohm, assuming the resistors are 0.1% ...
e.g. 680 = 512 + 128 + 32 + 8
If you really only want: 100 ohm, 150 ohm, 220 ohm, 470 ohm, 680 ohm and 1.5 k
you can use those exact values with mosfets to connect them to gnd as appropriate ... 6 way mux.

7th September 2019, 15:44 #10
 Join Date
 Jun 2017
 Location
 Bhubaneswar, India
 Posts
 39
 Helped
 4 / 4
 Points
 652
 Level
 5
Re: Exact resistance output?
I have ordered all the resistors and an analog MUX (MAX4781). This analog multiplexer is having a very low ON resistance of 0.7 ohm. I will tell you whether it works perfectly or not, It will take 910 days to meet those ICs.
Thank you all for your suggestion..
you can use those exact values with mosfets to connect them to gnd as appropriate ... 6 way mux.
+ Post New Thread
Please login