+ Post New Thread
Page 4 of 4 FirstFirst ... 2 3 4
Results 61 to 77 of 77
  1. #61
    Advanced Member level 4
    Points: 6,164, Level: 18
    kripacharya's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2012
    Location
    New Delhi
    Posts
    1,194
    Helped
    180 / 180
    Points
    6,164
    Level
    18

    Re: Does Solid State Marx Generators actually work?

    Interesting experiment, interesting results.
    I have a half-baked theory that your Stage3 Charge driver is malfunctioning. Refer again to my concern about exceeding Gnd1-Gnd2 isolation Max voltage.

    That would possibly explain some of your observations.



  2. #62
    Full Member level 2
    Points: 650, Level: 5

    Join Date
    May 2019
    Location
    Roskilde, Denmark
    Posts
    147
    Helped
    7 / 7
    Points
    650
    Level
    5

    Re: Does Solid State Marx Generators actually work?

    I summoned the strength to solder a couple of current sense resistors to stage 4 and do some measurements. It seems to me that the cap is discharging instantly through the diode, what do you think?

    Click image for larger version. 

Name:	current-1.png 
Views:	6 
Size:	64.4 KB 
ID:	154307

    If it does, why does it do it? I tried with faster, slower, bigger diodes and increase the time between Qc/Qd turns ON/OFF but none of that helped. An finally where does it discharge to?



  3. #63
    Full Member level 2
    Points: 650, Level: 5

    Join Date
    May 2019
    Location
    Roskilde, Denmark
    Posts
    147
    Helped
    7 / 7
    Points
    650
    Level
    5

    Re: Does Solid State Marx Generators actually work?

    I soldered some more sense resistors, and it seems it paid off. I believe I found the unwanted discharge path for C4 and C3

    Click image for larger version. 

Name:	marx-26.png 
Views:	8 
Size:	30.2 KB 
ID:	154314

    As you remember, stage3 and stage4 are the malfunctioning stages in this configuration. When all caps get charged, ONLY Qdischarge4 is triggered (for debugging purposes).

    Now how can the diodes D3 and D4 conduct?

    I believe it is because the caps reverse polarity, here is C3 when it discharges, as you can see it reverses polarity:
    Note 200V/DIV
    Click image for larger version. 

Name:	C3-discharge.png 
Views:	0 
Size:	14.5 KB 
ID:	154315

    How does Qd2 and Qd3 conduct when they are active OFF?

    Well I found some noise on Qd2 and Qd3 gates that could explain that. (Qd4 is ON, Qd5/1/2 are OFF - and all those signals are noise free)
    Qd2 Vge
    Click image for larger version. 

Name:	Qd2-Vg.png 
Views:	1 
Size:	21.1 KB 
ID:	154316
    Qd3 Vge
    Click image for larger version. 

Name:	Qd3-Vg.png 
Views:	0 
Size:	20.3 KB 
ID:	154317

    BUT WHY it does all happen when Qd4 is turned ON? I haven't the foggiest clue yet.



  4. #64
    Advanced Member level 4
    Points: 6,164, Level: 18
    kripacharya's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2012
    Location
    New Delhi
    Posts
    1,194
    Helped
    180 / 180
    Points
    6,164
    Level
    18

    Re: Does Solid State Marx Generators actually work?

    I don't get it.

    You are seriously violating the Absolute Maximum rating of Gnd - Gnd voltage tolerance of your driver ICs, and yet are not focusing on how to resolve an obvious problem.
    Why is this ? How are you so sure that this exceeding of max rated voltage is not causing any problems ?



  5. #65
    Full Member level 2
    Points: 650, Level: 5

    Join Date
    May 2019
    Location
    Roskilde, Denmark
    Posts
    147
    Helped
    7 / 7
    Points
    650
    Level
    5

    Re: Does Solid State Marx Generators actually work?

    Quote Originally Posted by kripacharya View Post
    I don't get it.

    You are seriously violating the Absolute Maximum rating of Gnd - Gnd voltage tolerance of your driver ICs, and yet are not focusing on how to resolve an obvious problem.
    Why is this ? How are you so sure that this exceeding of max rated voltage is not causing any problems ?
    I don't get it too....that is - what you are saying "Gnd voltage tolerance of your driver ICs"? What do you mean by that? And why aren't you on holiday like everybody else? You don't have an auto-camper?



  6. #66
    Advanced Member level 4
    Points: 6,164, Level: 18
    kripacharya's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2012
    Location
    New Delhi
    Posts
    1,194
    Helped
    180 / 180
    Points
    6,164
    Level
    18

    Re: Does Solid State Marx Generators actually work?

    Quote Originally Posted by Swend View Post
    I don't get it too....that is - what you are saying "Gnd voltage tolerance of your driver ICs"? What do you mean by that? And why aren't you on holiday like everybody else? You don't have an auto-camper?
    Is that a serious question ? Really ?
    Based on the spec sheets of your driver IC, the max tolerable voltage difference between GND1 and GND2 is 1200v before breakdown and catastrophic failure, presumably.

    Since your circuit exceeds these voltage limits, especially during discharge in stage 3 and beyond, I have repeatedly pointed out to you to check this issue.

    I live in India. We have different 'holidays'. We don't auto-camp. The land itself is our camp.

    Check your Absolute Maximum Ratings of your driver IC's. Get better ones, or cascade them or something. But that spec looks serious to me.



    •   AltAdvertisement

        
       

  7. #67
    Full Member level 2
    Points: 650, Level: 5

    Join Date
    May 2019
    Location
    Roskilde, Denmark
    Posts
    147
    Helped
    7 / 7
    Points
    650
    Level
    5

    Re: Does Solid State Marx Generators actually work?

    Quote Originally Posted by kripacharya View Post
    Since your circuit exceeds these voltage limits, especially during discharge in stage 3 and beyond, I have repeatedly pointed out to you to check this issue.
    Just to bust your theory I have measured the potential difference between GND1 and GND2 in stage3 and the reading was 200V and that is with 600V supply.

    You have to think of the chain of events, it starts with Qd4 turning ON and that starts a chain reaction. My theory now; it's the caps somehow.

    Quote Originally Posted by kripacharya View Post
    I live in India. We have different 'holidays'. We don't auto-camp. The land itself is our camp.
    And isn't that the perfect opportunity to be a local trendsetter? I have this one on my build list, maybe you could do the same with a TATA bus? You would make the news and hobnob with all the popular cricket celebs.

    - - - Updated - - -

    I tried something new...

    I removed C4, and it did nothing, so I put it back.

    I removed D4, and C3 charged up, and didn't discharge instantly, and the gate Qd3 and Qd2 were without any noise. So it seems without D4 stages 5+1+2+3 are working properly.

    But without D4 all stages will not discharge into the load. So either I have to figure out why D4 is problematic, or maybe use a MOSFET instead of D4?



  8. #68
    Full Member level 2
    Points: 650, Level: 5

    Join Date
    May 2019
    Location
    Roskilde, Denmark
    Posts
    147
    Helped
    7 / 7
    Points
    650
    Level
    5

    Re: Does Solid State Marx Generators actually work?

    I have a new theory as to what is wrong, is there an EE in the house that could confirm it?

    My new theory is that it's paracitics, so I added some stray inductance and capcitance to the simulation and it shows what I'm somewhat measuring. in this case I have 5 (c1-5) caps all charged up to 600V each, so I would expect 3KV output once all the Td's are ON, but here allmost 50% is lost due to paracitics.

    Click image for larger version. 

Name:	Screenshot from 2019-07-15 17-08-39.png 
Views:	10 
Size:	57.2 KB 
ID:	154419



  9. #69
    Advanced Member level 4
    Points: 6,164, Level: 18
    kripacharya's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2012
    Location
    New Delhi
    Posts
    1,194
    Helped
    180 / 180
    Points
    6,164
    Level
    18

    Re: Does Solid State Marx Generators actually work?

    Quote Originally Posted by Swend View Post
    I have a new theory as to what is wrong, is there an EE in the house that could confirm it?

    My new theory is that it's paracitics, so I added some stray inductance and capcitance to the simulation and it shows what I'm somewhat measuring. in this case I have 5 (c1-5) caps all charged up to 600V each, so I would expect 3KV output once all the Td's are ON, but here allmost 50% is lost due to paracitics.

    Click image for larger version. 

Name:	Screenshot from 2019-07-15 17-08-39.png 
Views:	10 
Size:	57.2 KB 
ID:	154419
    Interesting.

    I think it's time you posted some pics of your setup. Maybe there are some other obvious issues you have not considered as yet which might come to light with pics.



  10. #70
    Super Moderator
    Points: 257,348, Level: 100
    Awards:
    1st Helpful Member

    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    Bochum, Germany
    Posts
    44,911
    Helped
    13660 / 13660
    Points
    257,348
    Level
    100

    Re: Does Solid State Marx Generators actually work?

    Parasitic capacitances surely matter, surprising that you start now to think about it. 2 x 2nF however isn't but a shot in the dark and should be justified with datasheet specs and measurements. Are we still dealing with IGW15T120 IGBT switches? They have < 100 pF output capacitance, PCB capacitances per stage should be considerably lower.

    No idea about gate driver and DC/DC parasitic capacitances. You have the circuit at your fingertips and can easily verify capacitance assumptions.



  11. #71
    Full Member level 2
    Points: 650, Level: 5

    Join Date
    May 2019
    Location
    Roskilde, Denmark
    Posts
    147
    Helped
    7 / 7
    Points
    650
    Level
    5

    Re: Does Solid State Marx Generators actually work?

    Quote Originally Posted by kripacharya View Post
    Interesting.

    I think it's time you posted some pics of your setup. Maybe there are some other obvious issues you have not considered as yet which might come to light with pics.
    I just dismantled it, and ordered new pcb's, so when I assemble it again. In the meantime you can feast your eyes on the new layout, it's 66% narrower and then I won't stack it but rather do side-by-side to minimize distance.

    Click image for larger version. 

Name:	Screenshot from 2019-07-17 19-36-20.png 
Views:	7 
Size:	13.7 KB 
ID:	154452

    - - - Updated - - -

    Quote Originally Posted by FvM View Post
    Parasitic capacitances surely matter, surprising that you start now to think about it.
    I was living on the hope that it wouldn't be an issue, especially with only 20KHz. And if it was an issue it would be seen on the result, as I know no authorized method to estimate, quantify and measure parasitics.

    Quote Originally Posted by FvM View Post
    2 x 2nF however isn't but a shot in the dark and should be justified with datasheet specs and measurements.
    Not completely in the dark, I started with low values, and then I increased them until the simulation would show something I would recognize from the measurements.

    Quote Originally Posted by FvM View Post
    Are we still dealing with IGW15T120 IGBT switches? They have < 100 pF output capacitance, PCB capacitances per stage should be considerably lower.
    Yes but the 25A version STGW25H120F2, they were on sale from Arrow at ¢60 piece

    Quote Originally Posted by FvM View Post
    No idea about gate driver and DC/DC parasitic capacitances. You have the circuit at your fingertips and can easily verify capacitance assumptions.
    I'm not experiencing any gate driving issues, the signals are clean.



  12. #72
    Advanced Member level 4
    Points: 6,164, Level: 18
    kripacharya's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2012
    Location
    New Delhi
    Posts
    1,194
    Helped
    180 / 180
    Points
    6,164
    Level
    18

    Re: Does Solid State Marx Generators actually work?

    What 20khz are you referring to? And what is that yellow line on your pcb between drivers pads?



  13. #73
    Full Member level 2
    Points: 650, Level: 5

    Join Date
    May 2019
    Location
    Roskilde, Denmark
    Posts
    147
    Helped
    7 / 7
    Points
    650
    Level
    5

    Re: Does Solid State Marx Generators actually work?

    Quote Originally Posted by kripacharya View Post
    What 20khz are you referring to? And what is that yellow line on your pcb between drivers pads?
    20khz would be the maximum expected switching frequency, but for now I'm testing at one pulse only.

    The yellow line is a creepage cutout, i.e. the line will be milled through.



  14. #74
    Super Moderator
    Points: 257,348, Level: 100
    Awards:
    1st Helpful Member

    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    Bochum, Germany
    Posts
    44,911
    Helped
    13660 / 13660
    Points
    257,348
    Level
    100

    Re: Does Solid State Marx Generators actually work?

    Not completely in the dark, I started with low values, and then I increased them until the simulation would show something I would recognize from the measurements.
    Sure, if parasitic capacitance causes the voltage drop, it must have a similar value. But is the capacitance value realistic?

    Capacitance can be measured with LCR meter or various homemade circuits. Parasitic capacitance of the shown PCB is surely low, I guess not more than a few 10 pF. Unknown point is however the isolated gate driver supply.



    •   AltAdvertisement

        
       

  15. #75
    Advanced Member level 4
    Points: 6,164, Level: 18
    kripacharya's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2012
    Location
    New Delhi
    Posts
    1,194
    Helped
    180 / 180
    Points
    6,164
    Level
    18

    Re: Does Solid State Marx Generators actually work?

    Interesting.
    My rudimentary analysis indicates that each of your caps would have to charge through your load, in sequence starting with your last stage and working backwards to the 1st stage. That would take many mS to complete.

    Of course I'm just a noob, so could be totally wrong.



  16. #76
    Full Member level 2
    Points: 650, Level: 5

    Join Date
    May 2019
    Location
    Roskilde, Denmark
    Posts
    147
    Helped
    7 / 7
    Points
    650
    Level
    5

    Re: Does Solid State Marx Generators actually work?

    Quote Originally Posted by kripacharya View Post
    Interesting.
    My rudimentary analysis indicates that each of your caps would have to charge through your load, in sequence starting with your last stage and working backwards to the 1st stage. That would take many mS to complete.

    Of course I'm just a noob, so could be totally wrong.
    What do you mean by "would have"?

    noob at giving expert advise? or noob at EE? I hope you are not giving expert advise without proper edabord certification and authorization



  17. #77
    Advanced Member level 4
    Points: 6,164, Level: 18
    kripacharya's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2012
    Location
    New Delhi
    Posts
    1,194
    Helped
    180 / 180
    Points
    6,164
    Level
    18

    Re: Does Solid State Marx Generators actually work?

    Quote Originally Posted by Swend View Post
    What do you mean by "would have"?

    noob at giving expert advise? or noob at EE? I hope you are not giving expert advise without proper edabord certification and authorization
    Ah ha. My mistake in transcribing your circuit into SPICE. Ignore my previous post



--[[ ]]--