+ Post New Thread
Results 1 to 7 of 7

16th August 2018, 14:11 #1
 Join Date
 Sep 2016
 Posts
 59
 Helped
 0 / 0
 Points
 722
 Level
 5

Advertisment

17th August 2018, 03:16 #2
 Join Date
 Apr 2011
 Location
 Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA
 Posts
 12,336
 Helped
 2446 / 2446
 Points
 50,070
 Level
 54
Re: Pi or not Pi input filter for AC/DC switching PS?
The chief difference appears to be position of the coupled inductors (transformer icon). In schematic A it is placed in wires which carry alternating current.
In schematic B it is in a DC circuit, placed after a smoothing capacitor.
So it's a question where the inductor has greatest effect on waveforms applied to it.

Advertisment

17th August 2018, 08:30 #3
 Join Date
 Aug 2018
 Posts
 56
 Helped
 13 / 13
 Points
 369
 Level
 4
Re: Pi or not Pi input filter for AC/DC switching PS?
As I can see, the solution in B is slightly better. L1 is a commonmode choke, which is use to stop the commonmode noise in both ways. In theory L1 doesn't affect the input current since the current is differential. But in reality there always exists DC resistance for the coils inside commonmode choke. So the two 22uF capacitors and this small resistor will compose a PI RC filter. It is better than just use a single 47uF capacitor.
I also would like to say that both solutions have a shortage. There should be four small capacitors (from 100pF to 10nF, depend on the noise in the system) between the L1 terminals to the chassis ground. This will filterout the commonmode noise more efficiently. Because Pi filter (CLC) works much better than just an inductor.

Advertisment

25th August 2018, 17:11 #4
 Join Date
 Sep 2016
 Posts
 59
 Helped
 0 / 0
 Points
 722
 Level
 5
Re: Pi or not Pi input filter for AC/DC switching PS?
Thank you for the information. The scheme has been simplified. In real it it my attempt on the power supply 230V / +12V, +5V, 12V max 20W with high efficacy.
I use two Y2 capacitor between PE and + C14 L2.
I think it will be enough for a 20W power source.
Actually using 2x 22uf 400V is more because I have 100pcs in the drawer.
Full schematics

25th August 2018, 21:54 #5
 Join Date
 Aug 2015
 Posts
 1,130
 Helped
 434 / 434
 Points
 7,267
 Level
 20
Re: Pi or not Pi input filter for AC/DC switching PS?
In the above sketch (post #1) the cap C1 will add nothing to common mode filtering, but will improve DM filtering of the fundamental sw freq, due to the leakage L in the CM choke.
In the immed above it would be better to put your Ycaps by C13 and your CM choke immed after C13 for best CM performance, and make the Y caps 2n2 with a bead or 4E7 ( 1206) res in series with each for damping ...
Also C1 needs experimenting with size to get best CM noise reduction, again a damping resistor, say 10E may very well help with VHF ringing in this cap...
The tracks around the fuse are very long and will pick up noise, defeating any CM filtering ...
1 members found this post helpful.

27th August 2018, 22:23 #6
 Join Date
 Sep 2016
 Posts
 59
 Helped
 0 / 0
 Points
 722
 Level
 5

Advertisment

27th August 2018, 22:36 #7
 Join Date
 Aug 2015
 Posts
 1,130
 Helped
 434 / 434
 Points
 7,267
 Level
 20
Re: Pi or not Pi input filter for AC/DC switching PS?
... looking better ...
+ Post New Thread
Please login