T
treez
Guest
Large off-the-shelf power inductors shoudl not be used in products?
Hello,
Our engineering contractor wants to use the C1061-AL PFC inductor in a 150W PFC design..
C1061-AL PFC inductor:
**broken link removed**
We are convinced that such offtheshelf parts are only for single prototype units, and not for use in real products, since the part may well go obsolete, or become nil-stocked, (with a long lead time) do you agree?
If a PFC inductor is needed, then it should preferably use a standard offtheshelf core and former (eg ferroxcube PQ30 , ETD39, ETD54, etc etc). These standard formers and cores are standard and will never go obsolete, and will always be in-stock somwhere. Admittedly they need to be wound, and so it is effectively a custom part in the BOM, but that surely is better than using a part that has a high chance of going obsolete? After all, if one builds an enclosure round a part that goes obsolete, then the entire enclosure will likely need to be changed to accommodate whatever is found to replace the obsolete part.
Hello,
Our engineering contractor wants to use the C1061-AL PFC inductor in a 150W PFC design..
C1061-AL PFC inductor:
**broken link removed**
We are convinced that such offtheshelf parts are only for single prototype units, and not for use in real products, since the part may well go obsolete, or become nil-stocked, (with a long lead time) do you agree?
If a PFC inductor is needed, then it should preferably use a standard offtheshelf core and former (eg ferroxcube PQ30 , ETD39, ETD54, etc etc). These standard formers and cores are standard and will never go obsolete, and will always be in-stock somwhere. Admittedly they need to be wound, and so it is effectively a custom part in the BOM, but that surely is better than using a part that has a high chance of going obsolete? After all, if one builds an enclosure round a part that goes obsolete, then the entire enclosure will likely need to be changed to accommodate whatever is found to replace the obsolete part.