+ Post New Thread
Results 1 to 8 of 8

12th August 2017, 19:09 #1
 Join Date
 May 2010
 Location
 Vancouver, Canada
 Posts
 181
 Helped
 24 / 24
 Points
 2,179
 Level
 10
Software for modeling magnetics at 8.2 MHz
Hello!
I am looking for software tool to model EAS (electronic article surveillance) system – so called swept RF systems with central frequency 8.2 MHz.
To rephrase it in physical terms:
For closely spaced electrically small (x < λ/10) loops of different shapes I want to
 output spatial field distribution and determine field strength at different points in space
 determine coupling coefficient between the loops (S21)
 quantify effect of small resonant circuits placed in the vicinity of the loops on coupling coefficient (changes in S21 when resonant circuit is present).
Ideally software should have functionality to add discrete LCR components to the loops terminals – to study effects of matching networks.
If anyone has experience with this type of problems please recommend good software tool.
Ideally looking for open source but commercial software is of some interest too.

12th August 2017, 19:09

13th August 2017, 01:30 #2
 Join Date
 May 2010
 Location
 Vancouver, Canada
 Posts
 181
 Helped
 24 / 24
 Points
 2,179
 Level
 10

13th August 2017, 01:30

13th August 2017, 09:22 #3
 Join Date
 Jan 2008
 Location
 Bochum, Germany
 Posts
 40,581
 Helped
 12409 / 12409
 Points
 234,909
 Level
 100
Re: Software for modeling magnetics at 8.2 MHz
As you already pointed out, the EAS coils can be analyzed as pure AC magnetic problem, without coupling to far field.
The question has been often discussed related to wireless energy transfer problems. Suitable free and commercial are e.g. mentioned in this thread: http://www.edaboard.com/showthread.php?t=369972
1 members found this post helpful.

13th August 2017, 09:22

13th August 2017, 11:22 #4
 Join Date
 Apr 2014
 Posts
 1,314
 Helped
 537 / 537
 Points
 8,456
 Level
 22
Re: Software for modeling magnetics at 8.2 MHz
You can separate the EM problem and the lumped elements, with no loss in accuracy. Just place ports where lumped elements are connected, and get the overall response by connecting EM results (Touchstone *.s?p) and lumped elements in a circuit simulator.
Most EM solvers that support lumped elements also include them in an internal postprocessing step, after solving the EM model.

16th August 2017, 02:26 #5
 Join Date
 May 2010
 Location
 Vancouver, Canada
 Posts
 181
 Helped
 24 / 24
 Points
 2,179
 Level
 10
Re: Software for modeling magnetics at 8.2 MHz
FvM  that's a good insight: wireless charging is similar problem. The problem is almost purely magnetic radiation can be ignored at such small (in terms of wavelength) Still can not find software that does it conveniently. I tried CST  Transient solver takes hours to mesh, FD solver works sort of do not give me all the answers I need. Would be interesting to try Maxwell  I see many examples of wireless charging done on it but I do not have it.
FastHenry sounds interesting  where to get Windows install?
Modeling without matching components problematic. I need to evaluate range/sensitivity of the system and doing post processing for every data point takes lots of work. Doable of course ...

16th August 2017, 07:58 #6
 Join Date
 Jan 2008
 Location
 Bochum, Germany
 Posts
 40,581
 Helped
 12409 / 12409
 Points
 234,909
 Level
 100
Re: Software for modeling magnetics at 8.2 MHz
FastHenry sounds interesting  where to get Windows install?
A major FastHenry drawback is the lack of a convenient geometry editor.
I don't exactly understand the lumped components problem. It's straightforward to export a Spice model for the coil arrangement and use it in a regular circuit simulator. Particularly easy for small band problems.

16th August 2017, 07:58

16th August 2017, 08:28 #7
 Join Date
 Apr 2014
 Posts
 1,314
 Helped
 537 / 537
 Points
 8,456
 Level
 22
Re: Software for modeling magnetics at 8.2 MHz
I am working as an EM modelling expert since almost 20 years, including wireless charging optimization. My view: the beginner's approach to put "everything" straight into the EM model is the #1 reason for inefficient simulation and project delay.
Instead, I would at least start by separating the EM problem (EM model > coupled coils) from the matching aspect, and use EM to investigate this as a coupled coil problem. The coupling mechanism is magnetic field coupling, so this solution is accurate. Bringing things to resonance doesn't change the conclusions from the coupled coil analysis.
But never mind, use whatever workflow you prefer.

23rd August 2017, 16:33 #8
 Join Date
 Mar 2013
 Posts
 17
 Helped
 6 / 6
 Points
 943
 Level
 6
Re: Software for modeling magnetics at 8.2 MHz
try hfss. it is best frequency domain fem solver. you can include discrete component too in the fem solution or as external discrete component solved in the integrated circuit solver . Maxwell is an alternative only if you work with non linear ferromagnetic material. if you work with non saturating material , HFSS is more appropriate.
+ Post New Thread
Please login