Why inductors are not popular unlike capacitors

EDAboard.com Forum Index -> Hobby Circuits and Small Projects Problems -> Why inductors are not popular unlike capacitors

Author

Message

vishwa

Joined: 11 Aug 2005
Posts: 156
Helped: 12
Location: India

26 Oct 2009 13:20 What is the Need of Inductor

Hi,

I have the following questions about inductors.

1. What is the need of inductor?
2. If inductor is needed only as an energy storage element, why not we go for a Capacitor for energy storage applications
3. What is the relation between the inductor size and its inductance?
4. Typical applications of inductor?

Please help me understand the inductor.

Regards,
Viswa

vishwa

Joined: 11 Aug 2005
Posts: 156
Helped: 12
Location: India

26 Oct 2009 13:36 Why inductors are not popular unlike capacitors

Hi,

Can anybody let me know Why inductors are not popular unlike capacitors.

Purpose wise, both inductors and capacitors are come into the same category of energy storage element and timing circuit element

Thanks,
Viswa

jardila

Joined: 17 Sep 2009
Posts: 9
Helped: 1
Location: Colombia

26 Oct 2009 14:30 Re: Why inductors are not popular unlike capacitors

Because the inductors are associate with magnetic phenomena while the capacitor is associate with electric phenomena. The electronics circuits are electric phenomena ("more electric, less magnetic").

Regards:D

snafflekid

Joined: 09 May 2007
Posts: 121
Helped: 16
Location: USA

26 Oct 2009 15:15 Re: Why inductors are not popular unlike capacitors

Inductors are less "ideal" than capacitors. Inductors are also bulky compared to capacitors.

However in RF circuitry, inductors and capacitors are equally necessary.

Phytech

Joined: 30 Apr 2008
Posts: 89
Helped: 9
Location: USA

26 Oct 2009 19:51 Why inductors are not popular unlike capacitors

There are more variables for an inductor than for a capacitor. The way how one make an inductor strongly influence the performance, such as unloaded Q, cross talk, etc. So it's more difficult to make the inductor standard than to make a capacitor.

JoannesPaulus

Joined: 19 Mar 2008
Posts: 268
Helped: 44
Location: USA

26 Oct 2009 22:08 Why inductors are not popular unlike capacitors

I like to think that capacitors are local elements (they are only affected by what happens between the plates) while inductors are global elements (they are affected by their surroundings as well as their design parameters) and therefore it is just more complex to get them to work as you like.

Google
AdSense
Google Adsense

26 Oct 2009 22:08 Ads

vistapoint

Joined: 20 Feb 2005
Posts: 91
Helped: 2

01 Nov 2009 12:27 Re: Why inductors are not popular unlike capacitors

because inductors are difficult to manufacture with nice accuracy and Q value. Resistors and caps are easy to control the accuracy and more close to ideal components.

______________________________________________
low-cost resistors, capacitors, and LEDs at http://store.engeecorp.com

svhb

Joined: 07 Mar 2006
Posts: 101
Helped: 14

03 Nov 2009 19:10 Re: Why inductors are not popular unlike capacitors

As simple mains transformer = 2 coupled inductors...
A more complex smps mains supply uses a high frequency transformer = also 2 coupled inductors...
In every motor --> inductors
In relays, speakers, generators, ...
A lot in power electronics.
Just a piece of cable connecting the mains to your television = inductor...

I think people doesn't like inductors because they don't understand so well as a capacitor, which just hold a voltage applied to it. In fact an inductor just holds the current you have put in (put in a current somehow, short the inductor, and the current will flow forever (theoretically))

Stefaan

LvW

Joined: 07 May 2008
Posts: 1472
Helped: 242
Location: Germany

03 Nov 2009 19:32 Re: Why inductors are not popular unlike capacitors

svhb wrote:

.....................
I think people doesn't like inductors because they don't understand so well as a capacitor, which just hold a voltage applied to it.
Stefaan

Hi Stefaan,

I believe it's not a question of "like" or "dislike" . We all know that we meet inductances where ever we are and whatever we do.
However, it is a fact that engineers try to replace inductors by capacitors or by actively simulated inductive elements (GIC) wherever this is possible - especially in the field of analog signal processing. And there a good reasons to do this (as mentioned before by some other contributors). But, of course, it´s not always possible or wise.

svhb

Joined: 07 Mar 2006
Posts: 101
Helped: 14

06 Nov 2009 9:39 Re: Why inductors are not popular unlike capacitors

I think you are right for the signal processing side of it. Capacitors are far more better.

For me it looks like inductors are still important in power electronics, purely as energy storage component and not for its impedance characteristics.

Also for the more electromechanical devices (motors, relays, electromagnets), where the inductance is more seen like a parasitic effect for the function the thing is designed for.

Stefaan.

betwixt

Joined: 04 Jul 2009
Posts: 393
Helped: 64
Location: Wales, UK

06 Nov 2009 11:00 Re: Why inductors are not popular unlike capacitors

Nobody has mentioned one of the most important and common uses of inductors - to make resonant networks such as in radio tuning. It CAN be done without inductors but the alternatives are magnitudes higher in cost.

Brian.